Exploring nano-mechanics through thermal fluctuations

L. Bellon, Habilitation à Diriger des recherches de L’École Normale Supérieure de Lyon, 2010

oai: tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00541336

Abstract

This mémoire presents my current research interests in micro and nano-mechanics in a comprehensive manuscript. Our experimental device is first presented: this atomic force microscope, designed and realized in the Laboratoire de Physique de l’ENS Lyon, is based on a quadrature phase differential interferometer. It features a very high resolution (down to 10 fm/rtHz) in the measurement of deflexion, down to low frequencies and on a huge input range. The dual output of the interferometer implies a specific handling to interface common scanning probe microscope controllers. We developed analog circuitries to tackle static (contact mode) and dynamic (tapping mode) operations, and we demonstrate their performance by imaging a simple calibration sample.

As a first application, we used the high sensitivity of our interferometer to study the mechanical behavior of micro-cantilevers from their fluctuations. The keystone of the analysis is the Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem (FDT), relating the thermal noise spectrum to the dissipative part of the response. We apply this strategy to confront Sader’s model for viscous dissipation with measurements on raw silicon cantilevers in air, demonstrating an excellent agreement. When a gold coating is added, the thermal noise is strongly modified, presenting a 1/f like trend at low frequencies: we show that this behavior is due to a viscoelastic damping, and we provide a quantitative phenomenological model. We also characterize the mechanical properties of cantilevers (stiffness and Elastic Moduli) from a mapping of the thermal noise on their surface. This analysis validates the description of the system in term of its normal modes of oscillations in an Euler-Bernoulli framework for flexion and in Saint-Venant approach for torsion, but points toward a refined model for the dispersion relation of torsional modes.

Finally, we present peeling experiments on a single wall carbon nanotube attached to the cantilever tip. It is pushed against a flat substrate, and we measure the quasi-static force as well as the dynamic stiffness using an analysis of the thermal noise during this process. The most striking feature of these two observables is a plateau curve for a large range of compression, the values of which are substrate dependent. We use the Elastica to describe the shape of the nanotube, and a simple energy of adhesion per unit length Ea to describe the interaction with the substrate. We analytically derive a complete description of the expected behavior in the limit of long nanotubes. The analysis of the experimental data within this simple framework naturally leads to every quantity of interest in the problem: the force plateau is a direct measurement of the energy of adhesion Ea for each substrate, and we easily determine the mechanical properties of the nanotube itself.

Keywords

thermal noise, Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM), cantilever, Sader model, interferometry, dissipation, carbon nanotube, high precision, metrology, FDT, Kramers-Kronig, Elastica, stiffness, viscoleasticity, coating

Jury:

  1. -Arezki Boudaoud – Président du jury 
  2. -Joël Chevrier – Rapporteur
  3. -Matteo Ciccotti – Rapporteur
  4. -Philippe Poncharal – Rapporteur
  5. -Mark Rutland – Examinateur

Download PDF

Vieillissement des systèmes vitreux et rapport fluctuation-dissipation

L. Bellon, Thèse de L’École Normale Supérieure de Lyon, 2001

oai: tel.archives-ouvertes.fr:tel-00003649_v1

Abstract

This thesis presents an experimental study of aging in glassy material, aiming at testing recent theoretical approaches of the subject. In a first chapter, we introduce these new concepts : based on the analogy between spin glasses and structural glasses, they define the effective temperature Teff of these weakly out of equilibrium systems. This new observable is measured with the fluctuation-dissipation ratio of such a system.

The second chapter is dedicated to the study of the rejuvenation-memory effect in a polymer (poly(methyl methacrylate) or PMMA). Based on experiments on spin glasses, this work proves a strong analogy on fine effects in the behavior of these 2 different systems. Their common properties are theoretically described in the frame of a hierarchical energy landscape. This analogy makes PMMA a good candidate for a study of the fluctuation dissipation ratio, introduced in a third chapter. Our approach, based on the measurement of electric properties, is carefully analyzed to accurately estimate error bars. We demonstrate this way that we must improve our signal to noise ratio before drawing any conclusion.

In the last two chapters, we study a colloidal glass : Laponite. The measurement of Teff, using experimental protocol of chapter 3, proves this time a clear violation of the fluctuation dissipation theorem, in agreement with recent theories on aging. To check the intrinsic character of this property, we eventually propose a second determination via a rheologic study of this material. Un ultra-sensitive rheometer is set up, and preliminary results are presented.

Keywords: aging, glass, rejuvenation-memory effect, fluctuation dissipation theorem, out of equilibrium systems, PMMA, Laponite.

Jury:

  1. -Bernard Castaing, 
  2. -Sergio Ciliberto – Directeur de thèse
  3. -Jean-Pierre Hansen – Président du jury
  4. -Marc Mézard – Rapporteur
  5. -Gérard Vigier
  6. -Éric Vincent – Rapporteur

Download PDF